There are so many emotions today as our nation reacts to the death of Osama bin Laden. I am brought back to 9/11/2001 and remember my scattered reaction to the events of that horrific morning as the news became increasingly tragic. The surprise attack on American soil was credited to a single man: Osama bin Laden. There was, of course, an instant and intense desire to bring bin Laden to justice. We as a people felt vulnerable and wanted the person in charge to pay for his offense to our country.
Nearly ten years later, bin Laden is finally caught and killed.
I get nervous speaking about topics that involve either politics and/or religions, so I’m rather apprehensive putting my thoughts out there. Please understand that these are my first reactions and I will continue to process for a while…
This morning Joshua told me about the (relatively peaceful) riot that took place downtown State College with five to six thousand people. I’m trying to wrap my head around this. When the Twin Towers came down, there was heavy celebration from those around the world who believed the United States deserved such a drastic attack. I remember this feeling of horror that people who would celebrate such an appalling act.
I understand the differences. The celebrations last night were not in regard to an indiscriminate attack on a nation. Though we haven’t always succeeded in our goal, I know our military strives to keep any fire aimed toward specific individuals of threat. All noted.
That said. I am disturbed by the college riots throughout our country. Is this really how we choose to react to the news? Am I really alone? I have to say that some of the over-the-top celebrations (primarily comprised by college students who were not even teens when the 9/11 attacks occurred) seem strange and unfocused. My skeptical self wonders if this was just another reason to party as a group. I don’t know that this is the best way to react. But perhaps that is just me. Perhaps my reaction is colored by the speed with which college students seem to jump at any reason to riot.
My first reaction to the news was shock. Then I was flooded with the memories and emotions of that day almost 10 years ago – the frustration that Osama bin Laden and his followers deemed that ALL Americans were basically evil and needed to be destroyed. I thought of all the brave military men and women (along with unfortunate victims like Daniel Pearl) who gave their lives to the cause of protecting our country and bringing an end to Al-Qaeda and its terrorist actions.
So now I am processing. I don’t feel like running out into the streets and having a drink with my fellow Americans – especially with several-thousand college students who confuse me with their party-like response. While I am pleased to know that bin Laden is no longer with us, I am also aware that Al-Qaeda will not simply crumble with his death.
I am PROUD of our troops for their perseverance. I am amazed and humbled by their bravery. I celebrate them. I celebrate this victory. But I don’t celebrate with loud, drunken cheers that blood was shed. I celebrate with a (hopefully) dignified salute to a job well done and justice served. My celebration is juxtaposed with a renewed ache for all the people/families who lost so much in 9/11 and the following response by our country. My celebration is hushed, perhaps with a nod to those who stand by me in quiet contemplation of this giant accomplishment (that hopefully brings some people a little closure and/or peace). And my celebration includes concern for what comes next. And as a Christian, I am saddened that bin Laden never understood those he despised so thoroughly. I am saddened he was so consumed by hate that he was unable to see that the general evil persona he placed on all Americans was inaccurate. We have our flaws, but bin Laden’s opinion was extreme. I wish he’d been able see that while he was still on this earth.
I believe I am a minority in my response. I expect some might be confused, frustrated, or angered by my thoughts. Some might counter with arguments of how streets flooded with college students in a drinking frenzy is a completely appropriate and authentic show of celebration for the demise of a villainous personality that’s plagued our nation for a decade.
Like I said earlier, I am still processing the response of our country. I hope we do not take this event lightly, but rather use it to consider our motivations, our hearts, and our general respect for human life.
UPDATE: The more I ponder the situation, the more uncomfortable I am with the word “celebration.” The attack on 9/11 was borne out of hate, and to celebrate one’s death with such fervor also seems to be an action of hate. Neither sit well with me. I do not mourn the passing of Osama bin Laden, but neither do I celebrate it as if celebrating the win of a favorite sports team.
Therefore, I believe “celebration,” whether outward or inward, incorrectly describes my reaction to the news. Maybe “relieved” is more appropriate (though I am not naive enough to believe that the death of bin Laden means peace). Or perhaps I feel nothing beyond the resurfaced anguish of 9/11.
I am frustrated by extreme (particularly violent) reactions to those we do not agree with, do not understand, or of whom we do not approve. Regardless of my personal beliefs, I do not wish physical/emotional harm to those who do not share my beliefs. So this has been a difficult day of considering and reconsidering the appropriate reaction. It has also been a day of self-evalutation. I feel emotionally un-intelligent, because I’m not sure how to accurately label or describe this mesh of feelings churning within me.
Again, still processing, but I want to officially strike “celebratory” from the potential pool of emotions. I doubt I’ll post any more on the topic. I hope I didn’t offend anybody. And I appreciate the feedback I received from people by phone/facebook/e-mail. You really helped me work through my conflicting thoughts, and I feel better now than I did this morning. So grateful for friends who lovingly encourage, support, and challenge me!